FREE Shipping on Web Orders over $50 (lower 48 states only)


Amish Style Roll Butter 2lb.

SKU: 025555992020
(27 customer reviews)


Amish Roll Butter – The Way Butter is Supposed to Taste

This hand-rolled delicious, salted butter is some of the best butter you’ve ever tasted. Perfect on bread, in cooking, and for eating by the slice.

  • Old fashion, slow churn makes a creamier butter
  •   small batch method produces the highest quality butter


Ingredients: pasteurized cream and salt.

Weight 2 lbs

27 reviews for Amish Style Roll Butter 2lb.

  1. Anonymous (verified owner)

    Better than most other brands

  2. Melanie (verified owner)

    Found this specific brand Amish roll butter at Walnut Creek store in Ohio.
    Super happy see I could order it here.
    Came in great shape.

  3. Tracy Nicole (verified owner)

    I will not buy store butter anymore. Definitely ordering more.

  4. Wayne K. (verified owner)

    The butter is wonderful and really added to our Thanksgiving dinner. Family members even commented on how yummy the butter was on their rolls and mashed potatoes. Can’t wait to use it in making our Christmas sugar cookies! Thank you so much for a great product!

  5. Linda B. (verified owner)

    Quick to ship. All items packed well. Fantastic quality & wonderful service! Highly recommend & shop there frequently.

  6. Thomas Adamson (verified owner)

    Again, love this butter. We do buy this and those items above plus others when we visit family in Bloomfield, IA.

  7. Gina Gallien (verified owner)

    Absolutely love this butter!!

  8. Elizabeth (verified owner)


  9. Gia (verified owner)

    Amish roll butter is so delicious. I can’t ever go back to store-bought brands. I am addicted! I’ve also recommended it to other friends who now have to have it in their fridges too! Can say enough how creamy and perfectly salted it is. 100 percent yummy!

  10. Colleen (verified owner)

    Amish Style Roll Butter is so much better than commercially bought butter. Food items requiring butter, even taste better with Amish Style Roll Butter. It is a MUST try.

  11. John Emond (verified owner)

    Very good butter

  12. Wayne (verified owner)

    The best flavor ever!

  13. Grace Brown (verified owner)

    Love it and will order more

  14. Anonymous (verified owner)

    You can’t believe how good Amish butter is until you taste it. Definitely a revelation!

  15. Colleen K. (verified owner)

    Your products are always good, both in taste and how it is shipped.Thank you!

  16. Pat Nelson (verified owner)

    So rich and delicious.

  17. Anonymous (verified owner)

    Excellent service for pure products!

  18. Karen H. (verified owner)

    Love it

  19. MONA H. (verified owner)

    Unfortunately, this order did not make it to me. After being MIA for about 10 days, I called the store and spoke to a man who canceled this order and placed a new order. The new order is expected to arrive tomorrow!
    Thank you!!

  20. Steven Forrester (verified owner)

    We live in Texas and it was 5 days from the day it was sent out to the time we received the product , it came packaged in ice packs and a styrofoam box but like I said 5 days to receive it it has been on average of 105 degrees and the butter was completely melted and no good had to discard it

  21. Robert Quinonez (verified owner)

    You guys are great and I havent had any issues with ordering on your end. Unfortunately UPS lost my package and still hasnt responded to my missing package claim. I need my roll butter so ill be placing another order.

  22. Verified Buyer (verified owner)

    Delicious butter and it made it all the way across the country.

  23. Maximos H. (verified owner)


  24. Mark McFarland (verified owner)

    I like the Speedy service when you get your new store open I will probably come a few times more but right now I know what I want and if it’s online that’s what it’s really about anyway picking up what you need to get and it worked out perfectly thank you very much

  25. Ashley Gochenour (verified owner)

    Love it!

  26. K P. (verified owner)


  27. Jared (verified owner)

    Amazing! Best butter ive ever had!

Add a review

Q & A

There are no questions yet

Ask a question

Your question will be answered by a store representative or other customers.

Thank you for the question!

Your question has been received and will be answered soon. Please do not submit the same question again.



An error occurred when saving your question. Please report it to the website administrator. Additional information:

Add an answer

Thank you for the answer!

Your answer has been received and will be published soon. Please do not submit the same answer again.



An error occurred when saving your answer. Please report it to the website administrator. Additional information: