🧈 Amish Style Roll Butter – 2 lb.

The Way Butter Is Supposed to Taste 😋

Discover butter the way it was meant to be enjoyed — rich, creamy, and full of old‑fashioned goodness. This hand‑rolled, salted Amish‑style butter is crafted in small batches using slow‑churn methods that bring out a depth of flavor you won’t find in mass‑produced butter. Perfect for spreading, cooking, baking… or enjoying by the slice. Yes, it’s that good.


✨ Why Customers Love It

  • 🐄 Old‑fashioned slow‑churn process for a naturally creamier texture
  • 🧈 Small‑batch craftsmanship ensures exceptional quality
  • 🤲 Hand‑rolled for that traditional, nostalgic feel
  • 🧂 Perfectly salted to enhance every dish
  • 🍞 Versatile — from warm bread to cast‑iron cooking to pastries

🍽️ Perfect For

  • Fresh bread, biscuits, and rolls
  • Country‑style meals and cast‑iron cooking
  • Homemade pastries and baked goods
  • Everyday table use
  • Stocking the freezer or pantry

📝 Ingredients

Pasteurized cream, salt.

  • Susan King (verified owner)

    Butter arrived safely but had no gel packs. Spots of black mold on the rolls,sorry

  • Jared (verified owner)

    Amazing! Best butter ive ever had!

  • K P. (verified owner)

    GREAT BUTTER LOVE THE DOUBLE BAGGING WILL ORDER AGAIN, THIS BUTTER MAKES THE BEST PIE SHELLS AND COOKIES YUM

  • Ashley Gochenour (verified owner)

    Love it!

  • Mark McFarland (verified owner)

    I like the Speedy service when you get your new store open I will probably come a few times more but right now I know what I want and if it’s online that’s what it’s really about anyway picking up what you need to get and it worked out perfectly thank you very much

  • Maximos H. (verified owner)

    Delicious

  • Verified Buyer (verified owner)

    Delicious butter and it made it all the way across the country.

  • Robert Quinonez (verified owner)

    You guys are great and I havent had any issues with ordering on your end. Unfortunately UPS lost my package and still hasnt responded to my missing package claim. I need my roll butter so ill be placing another order.

  • Steven Forrester (verified owner)

    We live in Texas and it was 5 days from the day it was sent out to the time we received the product , it came packaged in ice packs and a styrofoam box but like I said 5 days to receive it it has been on average of 105 degrees and the butter was completely melted and no good had to discard it

  • MONA H. (verified owner)

    Unfortunately, this order did not make it to me. After being MIA for about 10 days, I called the store and spoke to a man who canceled this order and placed a new order. The new order is expected to arrive tomorrow!
    Thank you!!

  • Karen H. (verified owner)

    Love it

  • Anonymous (verified owner)

    Excellent service for pure products!

  • Pat Nelson (verified owner)

    So rich and delicious.

  • Colleen K. (verified owner)

    Your products are always good, both in taste and how it is shipped.Thank you!

  • Anonymous (verified owner)

    You can’t believe how good Amish butter is until you taste it. Definitely a revelation!

Leave a Review